In partnership with

Introducing Fair Game from Vanity Fair

Join Mark Guiducci for a series of wide-ranging conversations with cultural leaders from the worlds of Hollywood, Politics, Style, Silicon Valley, and beyond. 

On every episode, Vanity Fair pulls back the curtain on how some of the most interesting and powerful minds in our society work – and where they see us going. On Fair Game from Vanity Fair, no subject is off limits.

A WORD FROM OUR SPONSOR, MASTERS OF TRIVIA

Trivia is more than a game; it’s a global tradition of knowledge and competition. Masters of Trivia’s tournaments have gone live, with 30 fast, multiple-choice questions. Most correct wins. Speed breaks ties. Compete worldwide for a $MOT token prize purse, plus valuable in-kind prizes.

Get the entry link and reminders by email — subscribe free at PlayMOT.

—— ON THIS DAY ——

NOVEMBER 20, 1945

Nuremberg, Germany
81 years ago

The International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg, which opened on November 20, 1945, to try senior figures of the Nazi regime for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

On November 20, 1945, the International Military Tribunal opened in the Palace of Justice at Nuremberg, one of the few large buildings in the city still usable after bombing and with a prison attached. Twenty-two senior figures of the Nazi regime sat in the dock, among them Hermann Göring, Rudolf Hess, Joachim von Ribbentrop and Albert Speer. Judges and prosecutors came from the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain and France. The proceedings ran for close to a year.

Nuremberg had been chosen partly for practical reasons and partly for symbolic ones: it was the city of the party rallies and of the 1935 race laws. The indictment set out four counts: conspiracy, crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The last of these was close to a new legal category, created to cover atrocities committed by a state against civilians, including its own, in a way that existing international law had not clearly reached.

—— MARQUEE EVENT ——

International criminal law, the body of law that grew out of Nuremberg and led eventually to the tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda and to the International Criminal Court.

The prosecution built its case chiefly on documents rather than testimony, on the reasoning that the regime's own meticulous records would be harder to dispute than witnesses. Millions of pages were sifted. Film shot by Allied units entering the camps was shown in court, and the reaction in the dock was recorded by observers. The trial also pioneered the use of simultaneous interpretation, with interpreters working in four languages through headsets, a system developed for the occasion and later adopted by the United Nations.

Twelve defendants were sentenced to death, three to life imprisonment, four to long terms, and three were acquitted, which mattered as evidence that the court was not simply a formality. Göring took poison hours before his execution. Hess served the rest of his life in Spandau prison, dying there in 1987. Twelve further American-run trials at Nuremberg followed, prosecuting doctors, judges, industrialists, and members of the mobile killing units.

The objections to the trials were raised at the time and have not gone away. The charges were partly created after the acts they punished, the judges were drawn exclusively from the victorious powers, and one of those powers had itself invaded Poland in 1939 and carried out mass killings of its own. The defence that one was following orders was rejected, establishing a principle that individuals bear responsibility for criminal acts regardless of what they were told to do. The Nuremberg Code on medical experimentation came out of the doctors' trial and underpins modern research ethics. The line from this courtroom runs through the tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda to the International Criminal Court established in 2002.

—— WHY THIS MATTERS ——

  • It established that individuals are responsible for state crimes. Rejecting the defence of superior orders and trying officials personally rather than punishing a nation collectively set the principle on which all subsequent international criminal justice rests.

  • It created the category of crimes against humanity in practice. Atrocities committed by a state against civilians, including its own population, were brought within the reach of law in a way that earlier international agreements had not managed.

  • Its flaws are part of its legacy. Judges drawn only from the victors, charges defined after the fact, and the presence of the Soviet Union on the bench are the standing objections to the trials, and they shaped the design of later courts that tried to avoid them.

—— THE TAKEAWAY ——

Twenty-two men who had run a state went on trial at Nuremberg on November 20, 1945, prosecuted largely with their own paperwork, in a court invented for the purpose by the people who had beaten them. Three were acquitted. The principle that following orders is not a defence came out of that room, and so did most of international criminal law.

—— QUOTE OF THE DAY ——


“The wrongs which we seek to condemn have been so calculated, so malignant and so devastating.”

— Robert H. Jackson, opening statement for the prosecution at Nuremberg, November 1945

—— OUR QUIZ OF THE DAY ——

How much do you know about the Nuremberg trials, the charges brought, the use of documents and film as evidence, the verdicts, and the objections raised to the court itself?

Reply

Avatar

or to participate